2004 USA Softball Collegiate Player of the Year "Watch List"
| Player | University |
| Monica Abbott | Tennessee |
| Kelly Anderson | California |
| Nicole Barber | Georgia |
| Caitlin Benyi | UCLA |
| Tia Bollinger | Washington |
| Christina Clark | Fresno State |
| Megan Ciolli | Notre Dame |
| Aisha Franke | Massachusetts |
| Vicki Galindo | California |
| Jenny Gladding | Florida |
| Keira Goerl | UCLA |
| Michelle Green | Georgia |
| Andrea Hillsey | Purdue |
| Monica Hoffman | Oregon State |
| Alicia Hollowell | Arizona |
| Peaches James | Nebraska |
| Kami Keiter | Oklahoma |
| Oli Keohohou | BYU |
| Lauren Lappin | Stanford |
| Jessica van der Linden | Florida State |
| Caitlin Lowe | Arizona |
| Sarah Martz | DePaul |
| Jackie McClain | Alabama |
| Iyhia McMichael | Mississippi State |
| Brooke Mitchell | Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Kristen Rivera | Washington |
| Kristin Schmidt | LSU |
| Monica Schock | Michigan |
| Chez Sievers | Texas |
| Dana Sorensen | Stanford |
| Jamie Southern | Fresno State |
| Claire Sua | UCLA |
| Nicole Trimboli | Nebraska |
| Stephanie VanBrakle | Alabama |
| Mackenzie Vandergeest | Arizona |
| Kim Wendland | Georgia |
| Phelan Wright | Arizona State |
| Kristen Zaleski | Texas State |
| Emily Zaplatosch | UCLA |